qwxlea
European time-zone
Sweet romance and heroics, great stress-reliever
This is not hard historical fiction, it is a cross between a manhua and a fairy tale, turned into a tv-series, just to help set the right expectations. If going in, expecting something remotely historical, then they you be disappointed, and that would be a disservice to an excellent story.If you're wondering if you should watch it, as it is so long, just watch the first one or two episodes, it gives a good feel of what to expect. This is mostly a fun-series. There will be some tears, people do die, but their is no angst here, it's mostly sweet romance and heroics.
Production: The Long Ballad is based on Xia Da's manhua Chang Ge Xing, which was published from 2011 to 2016. The manhua has received numerous awards such as the Golden Dragon Award for Best Girls' comic and the Newcomer Award at the first Sino-Japanese Youth Exchange Cartoon Festival. [1] I haven't read the manhua (yet), but it as been translated and the parts I did read are fantastic. The story is good enough that I want to read the manhua, despite it (also) being terribly long. 9/10
Story: I hate spoilers, so I won't be adding any here. This is your basic fairy tale. Princess gets into trouble. Princess meets handsome prince. It takes them a while to figure things out. Plenty of people die... The story is not exceptional, but told well. The characters are believable, and make sense. Chinese series like to red-wedding endings, but this one had a (reasonably) good ending. Not too many open loops. But as said before, maybe the manhua is a bit deeper. But well... books vs movies is an eternal dispute, TLB is no exception. 8/10
Acting: Dilraba Dilmurat (the main reason I started to watch) is a beautiful woman, maybe one day she'll learn to be a great actress as well. The acting in TLB is only so-so, for most of the actors. Honestly, I found Rosy Zhao and Liu Yu Ning the best characters, they would score an 8.5/10, they showed real personal growth, many of the others a bit less. This is a long story with many characters, although nobody really shows deep character development, many acted really well and made the episodes fly by. I would say it is not disturbingly bad, but not great either. 7/10
Visual FX: As the story is based on a manhua, they decided to combine images and video together to tell the story. It was done really well. It made the story easier to watch, there are no bloody battles, those are replaced with images, and left to the imagination of the viewer. It kept the story light and fit well with the overall feel. The costumes and sets looked real enough, just a bit manhua-ish, but not distractedly so. Overall, I really liked it: 9/10
OST: The title song is very good, the tone of the song and the lyrics fit very well with the story, and even though it played a gazillion times, it did not get boring, a testament to a really well made song. There was a surprisingly large amount of songs in the series, which was a bit weird, but strangely I didn't hate it. I personally prefer an OST that stays in the background, highlighting the visuals, here the songs really were a goal in themselves. Not my thing, but it was still done with good taste and style: 8/10
Rewatch value: There are so many series to watch, that something must be truly exceptional or somehow personally resonate with you to watch it again. This series is way too long to just sit and watch again on a lazy Sunday afternoon, so I'll just skip grading this one. I probably won't watch it again (completely), but that's more because it's length then any other reason.
Conclusion: Just watch it. It is a light and happy story, with beautiful people and swords and costumes, what more do you want?!
References:
- [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Long_Ballad
Was this review helpful to you?
The Story: simple but satisfying. Cheating between friends and exes, and how to live after all that. Terrible in real life, great for entertainment value. What stood out for me that it was all believable. Nobody behaved in a way that makes you doubt the script-writers sanity. All the characters felt like real people. Because the whole thing is quite short, not everything was fleshed out as well as it could have been, especially the end could have used another hour or so, but overall it was a well told story.
The acting and cast was superb. None of the actors were on my favorites list, but all the characters were portrayed really well. One of the bad guys ( Shin Jae Hwi) did such a good job that I'm a bit worried I'll hate him when he's in something else. The female leads did great, the women they portrayed were far from perfect, but you can't help feeling for them. I especially liked the style in which the series was shot, not over-done, but the whole series felt a bit like 'french cinema'. The attention to detail, like applying lipstick as almost female body armor, made it a joy to watch.
The Music: this one is a bit harder to judge. The score always fit the scenes, and was even part of the story. Unfortunately I did not like any of the songs, so a seven out of ten maybe?
Rewatch value; I'll probably watch it again. The vibe of the show was really good, but it's not a complicated story with lots of details and / or layering, so it's not something you can watch over and over again.
Overall, recommended if you want to watch a shorter series, that shows real women, trying to solver their own issues, beautifully shot, with a well-integrated score.
Was this review helpful to you?
