I score shows based off of plot, characters (protagonists, supporting, and antagonists), feels (did the show make me feel what it wanted me to feel?), stickiness (how memorable was the show?), and ending (how well did everything wrap up? was the ending justified/satisfactory?). I translate my score into MDL's scoring system minus stickiness. I don't score stickiness until a month or so later and don't want to try tracking that on here.