wintersweet
mostly goofy fun with some heartfelt moments, but then it just ... stops
Honestly, I can't forgive it for just stopping so abruptly at the end. I admit that's affected by watching it in 2024 when it seems pretty clear that there will never be a second season. (I guess I'll be visiting AO3 for some resolution.)
It's mostly a silly show with a lot of meta-humor. If you don't enjoy the gaming jokes, trope references, and so on, it won't be your thing. I know there were a lot of jokes I didn't catch, but there were still plenty that I did, and a few times I was howling with laughter. There were some cringey jokes at the expense of some of the characters that I didn't love.
It has some surprisingly effective emotional subplots and relationships! Don't expect them all to have happy endings because it's a goofy comedy, though. There might have been a few tears shed in the audience at my house. Unfortunately the subplot I was most invested in is one that would only have been resolved with a second season, so. (muffled screaming)
I think the cast did a good job with their characters. It's broad comedy, no need to be super subtle about it. Part of the joke, I think, is that some characters know they're in a wuxia novel/game/show and some...do not.
The thing that drove up me up the wall the most (other than the final episode!) was actually the costuming. It's like their budget was distributed randomly. There are some great and totally OK costumes! But also there are a truly couple of the worst costumes ever (see Wang Wu's lavender single-cold-shoulder dress, which fits absolutely no part of her body--I could do better in 5 minutes on Shein). And there's just a lot of visible poor quality.
I could see the raw edges of materials more than once. I'm pretty certain multiple characters are wearing a visible underlayer with their robes that's just some loose tulle or cheap chiffon wrapped around their necks and tucked under, not even flattened/stitched down. It looks terrible! A lot of the hair accessories and other things look like I made them from the jewelry findings section of Joann's. I imagine the costuming staff were doing the best with what they had but wow, I feel bad for the time and/or money crunch that forced them into those choices!
(Maybe this is normal for lower-budget shows. I've only seen a handful of post-2010 shows and the others must have all had bigger budgets.)
It's mostly a silly show with a lot of meta-humor. If you don't enjoy the gaming jokes, trope references, and so on, it won't be your thing. I know there were a lot of jokes I didn't catch, but there were still plenty that I did, and a few times I was howling with laughter. There were some cringey jokes at the expense of some of the characters that I didn't love.
It has some surprisingly effective emotional subplots and relationships! Don't expect them all to have happy endings because it's a goofy comedy, though. There might have been a few tears shed in the audience at my house. Unfortunately the subplot I was most invested in is one that would only have been resolved with a second season, so. (muffled screaming)
I think the cast did a good job with their characters. It's broad comedy, no need to be super subtle about it. Part of the joke, I think, is that some characters know they're in a wuxia novel/game/show and some...do not.
The thing that drove up me up the wall the most (other than the final episode!) was actually the costuming. It's like their budget was distributed randomly. There are some great and totally OK costumes! But also there are a truly couple of the worst costumes ever (see Wang Wu's lavender single-cold-shoulder dress, which fits absolutely no part of her body--I could do better in 5 minutes on Shein). And there's just a lot of visible poor quality.
I could see the raw edges of materials more than once. I'm pretty certain multiple characters are wearing a visible underlayer with their robes that's just some loose tulle or cheap chiffon wrapped around their necks and tucked under, not even flattened/stitched down. It looks terrible! A lot of the hair accessories and other things look like I made them from the jewelry findings section of Joann's. I imagine the costuming staff were doing the best with what they had but wow, I feel bad for the time and/or money crunch that forced them into those choices!
(Maybe this is normal for lower-budget shows. I've only seen a handful of post-2010 shows and the others must have all had bigger budgets.)
Was this review helpful to you?
