This review may contain spoilers
The drama is very nice BUT not have a good explaining about the beginning and ending, alot of mystery not solve 1.why items from fire victims become supernatural items?
2.What the connection about the supernatural item and dream world?
3.From where the supernatural?
4.Did these items exist before the fire?
5.what is dream world actually?why the item become supernatural items because of the fire that happened there?
6. What about the dream world symbols in the items?,it reasonable if the item is marchandise of dream world,but how about the polaroid and the lighter?
7. How they know how to use the items?
8. Who jo se hwang actually? Why his father call him "monster"?Even though they are both same a disgusting monsters
9. why se hwang how about the items?
10. How to get them out of the album if the photo isn't ripped?
11. what happen with the bom in the train station???!
12. how kang joon out and back to the real world?
13. who is the women with the key necklace?
14. is jo se hwang really dead?
The case still reasonable until they said the dead of kang joon brother is connected with jo se hwang! It became very not make a sense because everything was related to Se hwang and kang joon, even they never meet before
and in the end jo se hwang did not receive the punishment by the law he deserved for his actions
The fantasy genre film originally is unreasonable,so if they want to make the genre of fantasy film they should be able to make all these things become connected instead of leaving questions to the watcher
It is unfortunate even though I felt that the film was very good at first
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Exited opening, but quesion absurd ending!
Honestly,, I really don't like actors, before I watched his drama "Your Honor" and I dropped it on ep 1, I think the expression of his facial movements is very exaggerated,so fake, so it seems to be deep emotional but doesn't get in the right place, this drama actually gets a very similar cast with "your honor" has cast with different personalityThe story of this drama at the end of every episode makes me want to continue it, just want to know how they ended it, but after ep 10 everything changed, it might seem absurd to me
Trains that have been told many times will be stopped, but are reassigned continuously
When investigating the death of the Det.han's stepmother, the forensic woman said that civil servants have personal data in the basic system, so they have their DNA, but why isn't someone's blood DNA there? It's not connecting! So absurd! Forcing to be mysterious!
Many questions have no answers, I'm still asking questions
1. Where did the police get photos of stolen jewelry?, jewelry was stolen!
2. Where did the mastermind know how to transport between dimensions?
3. If trains, weather, and time are the keys to crossing, it's not possible that only them can cross? Whereas the train moving from ilsung to mukgyeong isn't just one person on the train? , other people who are on the train when they want to go to mukgyeong,they go to mukgyeong in another dimension? So absurd
4. What are the requirements for opening the gate to another world? Why can suddenly cross to another dimension at last? What are the conditions? Make a question but no answer!
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
That is just my opinionthe storyline is too boring, feels long when watched, more boring than I imagined, I think just bored at the beginning of the drama (untuk 3 or 5 eps)
I don't think it's as interesting as people say,not as annoying as people say
The story is very ordinary, except that the actors are beautiful and the acting is not bad, I don’t know which point is good.
the annoying is not the role of the characters, but the script dan plot is twisted
too many words of outpouring ,cut off, long, and useless
Editing and cutting out parts is very bad, and unclear, many are displayed vaguely and get no explanation
Unclear ending,what happened with joon young? Why end like that?!
I try to give a good rating, but honestly it is not worthy ,, even though I think at least the ending will end well
too Arrogant towards the rating that has been obtained
some things that make me confused:
Ep 6. isn't that a one-way street? , how can his wife go home first without passing tae oh? and told him, she waiting at home?
what was the agreement made by sun woo with Da Kyung's father?
Isn't Tae Oh detained for 2 years? , how can he film a movie?
PS: for those who are not yet 20, wisely watch this movie, may be used as an education, but do not lose consciousness
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
This drama telling whole life of qianlong
This drama is very nice, the details are good, and the timeline is also good, acting good, editing good, Although the timeline is not explained, it is very clear, but some time is a little different from the real history, like:
1.the consort name consort mei,and her son (according to wikipedia)
2.consort jia 9 prince death in history is when he is two years,but in the drama he die when born
3.the die of consort shu
4.In history qianlong 14th son die in 1760 and 16th son in 1765, but in drama they both die together
5.and the last,even hongli said ruyi not care about her empress status so he bury and arrange her funeral lower than her status,but i still it not make a sense
For the first i think this drama is to fast because from eps 1 already tell about the love about hong li and ulanara,but this is long term line drama tell all about qianlong life,so this drama is good, although the drama has a fairly long episode of 87, it isn't boring No extra scene, just right
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
drama matches the name "行" telling the journey of changge to find her faith
Not very bad and good enough to enjoy the drama,, the acting is notbad,For that director, maybe this is his 2nd work that is still worth watching besides Ash of Love
2 female leads, 2 of them were separated from their group and also searched for by the group, and the same as when they were in 1 place with their group they were missed, quite annoying,,,
has a jumping scene, and at the beginning of the story the scene is still tolerable, in the middle and end getting worse ,,,jumping scene, but there are lots of scenes where they whisper and sometimes doing /saying somethings and we don't know what the real purpose , and sometimes in tense scenes they change it with another scene or replace it with a manga scene, quite annoying
And ep17, why did he suddenly become emperor? even though it's only been a few days? and has a mustache, should it? ,and if so why does the world seem so quiet? not fuss about their new king? and at that time changge should be more anger , but she is not
and sometimes the player's dialogue doesn't match and matches the next scene, some scenes are contradictory
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Watch like no watch ,waste time!
I did not understand what the initial call was, when young suk told Sunhee to come to her house and said her mother would burn her down ... and the secret room at SEOYEON's house was also on fire,,,and the next call youngsuk asked why SEOYEON did not come to his house, meaning the phone was received not counting down, but going forward, because the incident of being burned has happened,before of this i think the call is counting day 18 17 16 nov, but not,,,but why are youngsuk still alive? And what happens next with the secret rooms's fire(present)? Just pass without any reason
May of scene happens without any reasonable reason!
And so what the meaning of the end? I think i can understand the end not like the others comment said
Even though it was warned by her who was from present but it doesn't make sense If she can survive being pushed from the second floor because it was an accident that even she can't predict it doesn't make sense If she can prepare before, no matter what,, Moreover, there was quite a lot of blood flowing and many parts of her body that I think were broken from the position after she fall
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
there are some storylines that look a little pushy and , there are some stories explaining history
Maybe stilk worth it to watchA little boring,a lot of unimportant scenes
And the the action part compared to kung fu more to boxing or western martial arts
at first it was still quite connected, but then the scene seemed like something was missing, the incident seemed to happen suddenly, especially when the film duration was reduced,
for ep 27 the duration is only 35 minutes and even then there is a review or scene of the previous episode for 1 minute , and have some eps only 32 minute duration
in the previous episode there was nothing like that, so that it made a scene like it happened suddenly
the duration is getting less, it is not clear that the original was like that or was reduced by the website
after the antidote problem(do er la and tang fan), the storyline got more abrupt,all the problems happen suddenly, writing, arras and antidote relationship ?, how can they link arras and antidote just like that, so absurd
And it seems strange that Qingge and dora get close so suddenly. Tang fan and qingge are not close enough to confide
Most cases in this drama are 2 types of cases combined into 1 problem, which sometimes makes it too pushy and confusing
Ep 32 15:07 and 34 08:22
The scene is same
Ep 45 when li zi long use one bolang to know the others bolang ,, so absurd! Omaigot, how stupid tang fan ,coward ,fool ,Obviously reluctant
What i said , it would be better if the role of Li zi Long was a descendant of the Xia Dynasty, because if the Tang Dynasty was too far apart , same li family name
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
give some explanation about this drama for who not understand well
you could say that I wrote is not a review, more to the analysis of the story,because of my habit of watching as much detail as possible,
I wrote various questions that I did not understand in order not to forget while watching this drama,
and hope that everything is clear at the end of the story ,i wrote maybe 17 -20 questions almost everything was resolved, but there were some that I still confused
I want to write some irregularities that make me confused
1. suspect of the case always appear suddenly, shen da (opium smugglers),he had jumped to the lake to escape, it was unknown when he was captured, and was not chased while jumping into the lake, then the jumping scene to the lake was just a futile addition
2. zhou li xian (ilegal artefact seller) i think his case is separate from the case of the loss of the queen's painting,but when they lost the direction of the investigation suddenly become related
3. who and how they giving back shui yue face skin to xiao ke? While shui yue died after removing her face skin?
4. when looking for the bead from the clue is a puppet, how she know it related with general guo?, even though there is also a puppet show in the kingdom
5. Ming Hui was known to be martial arts from the beginning or not?,but for what she pretended don't understand martial arts in front of zhao lan zhi when he thought about killing him?but all people know she is the disciple of tian qiao?
6. What is actually the color of the bead received by Tian Shu? , when given by his teacher the colors of gold and purple, but when he showed them to yuanan the colors were blue and purple?and keep changing, change both colors,At first I thought I was switched while fighting with Tian Qiao, but it seems not
7. Why mule can see the future of yuan an?, it still makes sense if what he saw was during Yuanan Time Travel,but in ep 4 when he first time saw yuanan with woman cloth, it shows 4 memory of yuan an 2 when she time travel and 2 when she become a maid, but she become a maid after mule stole the bead and go back to suoluo kingdom, i think maybe wring editing
8. when yuan an know about the dead of tian shu And just only his soul left?
9. Why did Tian Shu chase mule after he had volunteered to give it to him?
10. at first I found it strange with the medicine given by ling xi to zhen zhen, but after thinking i thought it still made sense if ling xi died when the fire after planning to hurt the king, but at the last they said ling xi just the soul of aheng, so it makes no sense, because the memory recovery drug was given suddenly,
It is not part of Ling Xi's plan, so what is given to Zhen zhen is only the healing drug, and aheng not a doctor but lingxi yes, it make a sense if lingxi gave them the memory recover drug,but not with aheng he just good with his magic
11. what is the secret that the queen hasn't yet told?
12. Isn't there only the soul of the red dragon in the body aying ?, How can Tian Shu seal the red dragon body? His body was killed by aying right?, and how they have the release seal? If the master they said who seal the red dragon is tian shu? ,It was said the release seal was given by the sealing master, but Tian Shu sacrificed himself and sealed the red dragon without having a chance to give the releasing seal
13. why aheng can stole the bead back from yuan an without her permission? And the last piece of bead destroyed or not? If destroyed, its mead the bead stole by aheng
14. if a hand can grow back with a blue bat, why lingxi eyes cant?
"accept explaining what I question, but do not accept criticizing me for watching habits in order to understand"
I always think why continue watching if I don't understand what is being told
NOTE:
The internet says the kingdom of Suoluo is an India now,,BUT from what i search, based on the drama(the country located in the southwestern part of the tang dynasty province of annam),gestures of characters (salute by lying down and angling hands on the floor), word(announcement when king and queen looking for doctor to have heirs)i scan and translate with tamil it not have a result but have result with thailand language, room decoration( elephant), war with champa kingdom (now vietnam) everything shows that Suoluo(娑罗)is Thailand in dynasty tang era years, all match,,,,,tian zhu (天竺) is india, kang kingdom (康国) is 西藏 xi zang, tibetan
Thats all my wikipedia haha
Not very clear, i think have some problems not solved ,some story not make a sense and very forced to connect , the plot is complex ,at least almost everything was resolved ,,and quite interesting to watch even the ending maybe can be said not happy ending? ,,but not just happy ending is a ending, at least the story ends well without hanging ,,,the point is not too bad for watch
Was this review helpful to you?
One of the best historical drama
nice director ,nice story, nice acting ,nice scriptwriter,the drama is interesting and was already full of mystery from the start,but all is clear at the end of drama ,when i completed the drama ,i listen the novel a little in YT and i think the drama version is more good ,some story is different from the novel but the plots is better like that, the heartache feeling when finished the drama, when we found a good drama , i save 53 54 episode end when i rewatch it ,the feeling have not faded, especially when the ost is playing (´⊙ω⊙`)(´⊙ω⊙`)(´⊙ω⊙`)Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
forcing to be happy ending with logic with 2 special episode
CONTAIN SPOILER DETAILS ,SORRYforcing to be happy ending with logic with 2 special episode
the drama scene looks like combining eternal love, ash of love, love and redemption scene, but has a slightly different story,, jump and blind like eternal love, tragic love and punishment like ash of love, forbiden love like love and redemption
The first 18 episodes were very boring for me, I liked when they went to the mortal realm(around eps 18)
actually the story is good too bad, the acting is actually quite good,but the editing make me speechless
The storyline is very weird messy, it makes me keep thinking, why is it like this, so I can't focus on watching, what's the point of watching drama if you don't understand the story? and give high rating just because a little romance?
i really cant give high rating just because a little romance, nothing special romance just
can only be accepted if you are a beginner watcher ,i already watch alot of drama like this and more focus with the details
the story of lead CP is one of them accepts one of them refuses continuously kike that until the end of the story.
I enjoy the friendship of yumo, yandan and yinyuan,
yumo at the beginning looks very nerd, but I like the character, love but not force, envy but not hate
and for the another support CP, i like them too,,but their acting and story still looks very newbie, it's good enough
I am very impressed with the directors and editors, they destroy people's work, the edits are very obvious reversed in the scene,, inconsistent in the use of words in each dialogue, loopholes everywhere,,I AM VERY SURE THE EDITOR IS VERY SLEEPY WHEN EDITING OR NOT INTENTION
the story is boring at the beginning, a lot of new things keep popping up plus the editing are very messy, it seems that all things happen suddenly for no clear reason,, even they explain it later about heaven demon war, but the story sequence is very messy, and not only that,, Inconsistent dialogue or mispronunciation but the director was not aware when shooting, and inconsistent scenes ,, are they not briefing before shooting ?
I want to pretend I didn't see it but to much,
I don't know how many times I sighed and wanted to drop this drama, BECAUSE THE LOOPHOLE IS SO OBVIOUS!
?(1) MESSY CHAIN STORY,, WRONG SCENE,,BAD EDITING,SHUDENLY SCENE
1. Sixuan, her betrayal story is only short story,but in my opinion the sequence of scenes is very chaotic, its better if she appeared first and then gave the scene she betrayed, but its not! and it seems that Yinyuan has a relationship with Sixuan but it's not clear what.
2. the effect of skill not match with the action they do, and sometimes dont understand what they do for
3. the demin and heaven war part, really really mess, the story sequence should not be like that, although it will be explained later, it's still unacceptable,, war begin shuddenly, end shuddenly
4. ep 26, tang zhou's master left two objects, the hairpin and magic weapon, that magic weapon is one of the 7 magic tools to be burned when yandan pretends zhixi to catch the traitor which should have been burned
5. i know yumo know about ziling identity,but i shocked when yandan know about it too, when? they both not look well from the first.
when ep 21,, 5:21 , i think yandan already know the real body of ziling,,,but why 23:11 she look like she didnt know about that and joking him just a little turtle
7. ep 22, heaven emperor said to make yinyuan easier to investigate the case, he will have all his memories, but when reincarnated to mortal, luming said yinyuan celestial power and memory will be seal by celestial armor, but in ep 47, they said again that the memory that should be kept is manipulated by someone
8. ep 33,,when attacked by shengde,, yandan said "quick, i can't hold it anymore" but they havent told tang zhou to eat the pills zhao yan gave first,, i think the scene was reversed, i was confused why suddenly told to be hurry, what action to do ?apparently told him to eat the pill
9. ep 56,, what?!I'm sure this is wrong,, isnt the 3 神器 (celestial artifacts) already stolen by the mastermind? the editing show yinyuan healing with 3 stolen artifacts and its go in to his body again,but the remaining artifact (dizhi) they have not in there,,
proved by ep 57,, 10:39 the stolen 3 celestial artifacts come out from MASTERMIND body, and yandan get it back the 3 artifacts
?(2) PRETENDING STUPID AND USELESS ACTION
1. yandan go to ask luming to help her find a book that can help her practice to protect herself from yinyuan, luming said all the book in yanxu palace, and her dont want to borrow with yinyuan but all the book is her punishment and she can access all the book
2. ep 6, Yandan was punished for writing heaven's rules with a very heavy pen, she lifted up very hard, she but could laying sleep by biting the pen, isnt it pinched?
3. ep 11, yinyuan craving a lotus burning pot to yandan, but yandan She didn't realize he knew who she was
4. ep 12, yumo can check Yandan's lotus heart only half, but yinyuan can't?, even though he has no doubt that it wasn't zhixi who helped him, and he believes she was yandan, but he didn't prove it by checking directly ,even he has that ability to check
5. ep 16, 14:30 ,when zhixi see yandan stuff, the blue bottle she gave her,, how can the note at the bottle? ,ep 13 11:09 the brokenheart yandan already keep the bottle with the others one in the locker, do you think her mood at that time still in the mood to write that note?
6. ziling afraid the others 妖 know about his real body,but he is in human world for long time ago and he show his skill in the other when fighing so why they dont know?
7. Yumo who thinks Tangzhou is the reincarnation of General Huode is very forceful, even though he has seen Huode, and even though there are only 2 people left who have participated in 2 wars, War of Genesis and God Demon War ,how can?! I'm speechless
8. ep 18,,,what makes me wonder is, if after cutting the horn can perish, why did he do it? if he perishes he unable to find yandan, what's the point? does he know zhaolan will give him elixir?
9. ep 40,, does yandan not eat antidote from tangzhou?, if they eat why do they still think the frog is from the lake? and if she have eaten why not heal? so that thing cant be called antidote
10. are all who reincarnated from "yewangchuan" not born from zero? yandan just lose her memories, does it make sense? many souls are reincarnated through yewangchuan, if all of them go down to mortal realm in adult form wouldn't it be very strange?even though yandan was forcibly passed down but the main reason she cant reincarnation is because she can't forget her memories,she should be born from zero.
ok, lets talk about the other route, from the heaven portal, yingdeng and yinyuan seem like reincarnation from the zero, from child,, but yinyuan betrayer servant go down in adult form?! ARE YOU SERIOUS?
12. THE LAST AND IMPORTANT ONE,, IF 2 SPECIAL EPISODE IS THE ENDING, TO FORCING, WHY? PRIMODIAL LORD,RANQING ,SACRIFICE HER PRIMODIAL SPIRIT TO MAKE A SHIELD BETWEEN DEMON AND HEAVEN REALM ,, IF YINYUAN CAN BE REVIVE SO RANQING CAN BE REVIVE TO EVEN IF THEY SAID STILL HAS A LITTLE SOUL SPIRIT LEFT LIKE THE HEAVEN EMPEROR ,,, IF YANDAN CAN BE REVIVE TOO ,SO ZHIXI NO NEED TO GIVE YANDAN HER HALF OF HEART.
?(3) WRONG WORD
1. ep1 yingdeng said her real body is dizun (emperor) (帝尊) lamp wick, ep 4 he said that he used to be a subordinate of dijun, and also the lamp wick on his desk,and this is the true,,, ,wrong word
2. ep 5,, female servant said her age is young but she can write the stoey "war of genesis(创世之战)"then yinyuandijun reply"是她写的创世之战"(she is who write the story war of genesis?), but he asked to see the script,,if he said like that i think he is know about that story script first and ask someone to find the writer,if from beginning he dont know about the story he should said "她写的是创世之战?"(she wrote about war of genesis?)
3. yandan when find out yumo is the black fish, she said apparently you're the fish i raised for 800 years,, what? didn't yandan just become human form for 500 years? and worked for beiming for 200 years?since the beginning the black fish lived in the pond of beiming place for long time ago when the war of genesis
4. ep8 funeral of the dijuns, said wrong name ,ep 7 when war the emperor said wanyue,, but when funeral the announcer said wanyun ,the right one is wanyun
5. ep 16,, 26:56 when yumo cut his horn,, zhaolan read the book, she said "剜角之人灵力盡散而亡" but the book clearly write ""剜角之人'多有'灵力盡散而亡" obviously just memorize the script, she can just read the book
6. ep35,,37:41,, yandan said this place is the place to find memories that the old woman(老夫人)said? the right one is 老人(the GUY who save liuweiyang),,, im wondering which old woman told to them about memories ???
QUESTION
1. is there no different time of between mortal realm and the heaven realm? ep 18 the narrator said "花界一日凡间数年,3界重分之后,人妖共存一界" ,if they in one realm why can flower clan 1 day human view years? they are in same realm! ,,so if the flower spirit and human in one frame so how many days go? 1 days or few years? ,but when yinyuan go back to heaven it seems no there is no time difference between heaven and human realm,
and ep 46 zhixi said 20years ago heavenly annouced yinyuan death
which is true?
note : the last 2 special episode maybe just for comfort? i dont know how is the novel but if this 2 sp eps is the ending it not make a sense
If I wrote something wrong, please comment politely
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
a bunch of short clip?
maybe those who feel this drama is good, just because of the romance, those who are satisfied with a little romance , so if someone gives a bad rating they will be judged, maybe there are some scenes that make me touched, and sometimes comedy but most of them feel very lame and the romance sometimes is weirdbad editing and bad scene viewing, jumping scene(not complete showing the useful scene,skip and skip)
from the beginning of these 56 episodes, can this be called a drama? I think this is a bunch of short,,, if in Kdrama it's called "special episodes"
why?
since the beginning of the drama, every time they want to do an action, there is see no action, only showing the result
I've never read the novel, but I'm sure the novel has alot of seasons, but in my opinion the scriptwriter is not good at choosing and sorting out what scenes are important so that from the beginning to the end the drama only show a short part and then proceeds to other scenes, too many unnecessary scenes. makes the first 22 episodes feel very long and unimportant,, in part 2, I thought it was getting better, but it didn't, the same misunderstanding happen again and again, in the first 8 episodes there had been about 3/4 times the argue between FL & ML,, character of FL which in part 1 really like, makes me hate it
they focus too much on the FL&ML scene so that they forget about other SUPPORT COUPLES, while the FL&ML romance is very long & very slow burning (FL & ML love story only starts at the end of part 1, and even in part still in the stage FL not have good feeling for ML) and makes the other couple not have enough scenes, and support couples together are very unreasonable, there is no obvious romance between them but directly together, waste of using cast, even though 56 episodes is enough to make the story very very clear plot and help some of the support cast develop the acting for newbie
the unstable voice made me keep adjusting the volume of the drama while watching, because there was no dubbing, when the cast spoke their mouths seemed to be gargling, if there were no Chinese subtitles maybe I really didn't know what they were talking about ,especially the words and language they use very rarely, even though I know chinese, still feels very unfamiliar
a crazy part like short clip and ridiculous scene (just a part, because too much)
1. ep 12, the medic said the arrow's head only appeared slightly on the surface of the body, if you want to take the arrow out, you have to cut the wound, but the medic is not good at sewing, shaoshang use a string, does it make sense? Even hard objects are difficult to put into a wound, but a string?, even though it is the strongest string, its call strong, because not easily broken by sharp objects, and the arrow's head has a sharp side, pulling the arrowhead with a string is like slicing a wound! does this action not need to stitch the wound?
2. ep 15 ,why they suddenly talking about huangpuyi?when huangpuyi send the cart for 3rd aunt?
3. suddenly shaoshang's father was said to be rebellious, during episode 46 I thought there was a scene helping his father, but it's been 5 days, are you serious?!
4. ep 44, shaoshang went tongniu to save her father, and to meet someone in prison, she intentionally stole 2 bread, how she sure that she is who is just a petty thief that stole bread, will be locked up together with important criminals?
5. little yue masquis said , miasma is not toxic, but why do the pengukun still get side effects? and suffering asthma?
大母,granny
大父, grandpa
君姑,mother in law
君舅,father in law
阿父,father
阿母,mother
君公,how to called male?
女君,how to called female?
舅父,uncle from mother
舅母,uncle's wife from mother
姑父,aunt's husband from father
姑母,father's sister
伯父,uncle, father's elder brother
伯母,uncle's wife from father's elder brother
叔父,uncle, father's younger brother
叔母, uncle's wife from father's younger brother
姒妇 ,brother's wife , sister in law
阿紫/阿姐 a zi ,sister
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
a bunch of short clip
maybe those who feel this drama is good, just because of the romance, those who are satisfied with a little romance , so if someone gives a bad rating they will be judged, maybe there are some scenes that make me touched, and sometimes comedy but most of them feel very lame and the romance sometimes is weird
bad editing and bad scene viewing, jumping scene(not complete showing the useful scene,skip and skip)
from the beginning of these 56 episodes, can this be called a drama? I think this is a bunch of short,,, if in Kdrama it's called "special episodes"
why?
since the beginning of the drama, every time they want to do an action, there is see no action, only showing the result
I've never read the novel, but I'm sure the novel has alot of seasons, but in my opinion the scriptwriter is not good at choosing and sorting out what scenes are important so that from the beginning to the end the drama only show a short part and then proceeds to other scenes, too many unnecessary scenes. makes the first 22 episodes feel very long and unimportant,, in part 2, I thought it was getting better, but it didn't, the same misunderstanding happen again and again, in the first 8 episodes there had been about 3/4 times the argue between FL & ML,, character of FL which in part 1 really like, makes me hate it
they focus too much on the FL&ML scene so that they forget about other SUPPORT COUPLES, while the FL&ML romance is very long & very slow burning (FL & ML love story only starts at the end of part 1, and even in part still in the stage FL not have good feeling for ML) and makes the other couple not have enough scenes, and support couples together are very unreasonable, there is no obvious romance between them but directly together, waste of using cast, even though 56 episodes is enough to make the story very very clear plot and help some of the support cast develop the acting for newbie
the unstable voice made me keep adjusting the volume of the drama while watching, because there was no dubbing, when the cast spoke their mouths seemed to be gargling, if there were no Chinese subtitles maybe I really didn't know what they were talking about ,especially the words and language they use very rarely, even though I know chinese, still feels very unfamiliar
a crazy part like short clip and ridiculous scene (just a part, because too much)
1. ep 12, the medic said the arrow's head only appeared slightly on the surface of the body, if you want to take the arrow out, you have to cut the wound, but the medic is not good at sewing, shaoshang use a string, does it make sense? Even hard objects are difficult to put into a wound, but a string?, even though it is the strongest string, its call strong, because not easily broken by sharp objects, and the arrow's head has a sharp side, pulling the arrowhead with a string is like slicing a wound! does this action not need to stitch the wound?
2. ep 15 ,why they suddenly talking about huangpuyi?when huangpuyi send the cart for 3rd aunt?
3. suddenly shaoshang's father was said to be rebellious, during episode 46 I thought there was a scene helping his father, but it's been 5 days, are you serious?!
4. ep 44, shaoshang went tongniu to save her father, and to meet someone in prison, she intentionally stole 2 bread, how she sure that she is who is just a petty thief that stole bread, will be locked up together with important criminals?
5. little yue masquis said , miasma is not toxic, but why do the pengukun still get side effects? and suffering asthma?
大母,granny
大父, grandpa
君姑,mother in law
君舅,father in law
阿父,father
阿母,mother
君公,how to called male?
女君,how to called female?
舅父,uncle from mother
舅母,uncle's wife from mother
姑父,aunt's husband from father
姑母,father's sister
伯父,uncle, father's elder brother
伯母,uncle's wife from father's elder brother
叔父,uncle, father's younger brother
叔母, uncle's wife from father's younger brother
姒妇 ,brother's wife , sister in law
阿紫/阿姐 a zi ,sister
Was this review helpful to you?
Mysteru drama with backforth plot, not confusing,, but curiousing
Mystery drama with a back and forth plot, but not confusing, just make you curious, from the beginning the drama makes us wonder why this is like this , why is like that, is he the mastermind or is he the mastermind?, Even though the plot goes back and forth now and in 2018,2017,1991,1995, but the story is pretty clear, just curious,,not twisting brain,,, and actually i already guessed who the killer from the storylineWhen I saw them climbing the mountain, all I thought was "aren't they tired?" ,, but they did not disappoint their tiredness, the editing was also quite good, everything should be displayed is shown,, only LYS ..... Where is she?
And the soundtrack Even it's not much, it really gets the point of the feeling,,, mystery ost, and the last eps gugyeong ost
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Worst editing,, jumping scene cutting scene,, different duration check
Episode :36 + 1 extra 1++ minute (ep37)Duration : not stabil, some have special version,
Extra scene special
Ep6, 25:27-25:57
Ep12,, 21:35 - 24:16
Ep17,, 39:39 - ?
before watching this drama, I felt 36 episodes were too few, especially when I know a lot of characters, but I feel grateful for only 36 episodes because it was enough!, with very bad editing it made me tired to continue, not bored while watching it ,, but very disappointed with the editing
hmm yaah, my conclusion for this drama is, a drama with a mix of various wuxia dramas ,, with very bad editing for viewers who are concerned with good details ,, jumping scenes, cutting scenes, scenes that are messy until the editor is also confused ,, a lot cast names, conspicuous or inconspicuous , ending that was too pushy to be a happy ending, and
but for couples who should or can have happy endings they ruins it (yu&liu,,, gu&cao),, It is unfortunate
the first impression of this drama is, this drama is like a mix of various kinds of wuxia and wulin dramas(untamed, jinyong's novels)
There were too many names and characters for 36 episodes, so it was very confusing, especially in Episode 1, there were many cast names, and many cast names were only mentioned, if the name is ignored, sometimes it is even discussed again in the next episode
And the name is similar
From the half of the drama, i getting boring, hmm maybe cant said boring, i just hate watching dramas with really bad editing ,,, jumping scenes, scenes that are not clear and don't fit the plot, scenes are unnecessary
#EDITING #
Very bad editing,, worse cutting scene, jumping scene, its better in beginning but worst in the middle until the last, all incident happpen suddenly,, and use using same scene for different episode and condition,
# Ep 1, sound when the subordinate , fengpengju (viceleader of tianchuang) , reporting the remaining stubborn generals who has been dealt, same as ep2 16:33
# Ep13, when caowenning go out and chasing a xiang, sama with ep 8 08:42
#DIALOGUE THAT KEEPS(spoil) CHANGING AND SCENE WAS PUT IN FHE WRONG EPISODE
# Ep19, i replay N Times and why i really confused! First longque say rongxuan ask his wife to give the key to his master (yebaiyi),but his wife give the key to fairy healer couple? ,then later longque say again he very apologize because cannot give the key to yebaiyi? SO WHO ASK WHO?!
#Ep21, 19:23 ,, yuqiufeng meets zhaojing and encodes xishanggui gossip, and zhaojing mutters "the person who was sent to kidnap Luofumeng (xishanggui) all died in yueyangsect, don't be in yuqiufeng's hands", EP 17 32:00 ISNT ZHAOJING ALREADY KNOWING THAT YUQIUFENG IS WHO HELPED XISHANGGUI? AND HE ASKING WHAT THE CONNECTION OF BOTH?AND ASKING 1 MORE GIRLS IS WHO?And now he's panicking on his own?
#Ep22 ,, 4:36, axiang also said that gao xiao lian being kidnapped! But zhouxu and wen already know when just escaping from heroes assembly and go to cave ,but wen and zhou seem didnt know about it
#ABSURD # (SPOIL)
1. When chengling is rescued from scorpions and returns to Yueyang Sect, and meets Axiang, talks and calls Zhouxu as "Teacher" Axiang seems to know immediately that Chengling has become Zhouxu disciple , even though previously Chengling also liked to call him with that call.
2. ep 12,, when wen and zhou Take Chengling back to Yueyang Sect, the guard outside the gate just realized Chengling who was they're looking for when chengling walk to them , even though Chengling, Wen, and Zhou were talking in front of the gate.
3. When zhaojin found zhen couple and want the key, zhen wife give him a poison, and give him an antidote for a month, but why zhaojing still alive when zhen couple being killed?
4. Aren't the ghosts no longer cooperating with scorpiom king? Why still work with him? And being poisoned?
Was this review helpful to you?
multiple solving case
not bad, the story end with 5 cases and 1 main case ,,dividing the drama into 21 minutes and 32 episodes is really unnecessary, just a waste of energy and time, in my opinion all the cases are ok, there are concepts that I have seen in other dramas, and the path of evidence is quite complete and clear, at least no question left ,for corpses and wounds not very sensor but not very focused too
i just feel weird with the interaction of the female duo, suddenly and fake or pretend, I don't get the feeling, maybe it's unique and comedic for some people
case 1 mental hospital
case 2 serial suicide
case 3 terror
case 4 insulin case
case 5 lost and found
Was this review helpful to you?